- cross-posted to:
- selfhosted@lemmy.world
I’ve read that sharing access to others is more cumbersome than Plex, requiring Tailscale or similar? Trying to get my family members and friends to do that is unfortunately not viable.
That’s not true, if you don’t care about security you can open the port. I use a reverse proxy (caddy, super simple) which is somewhere in the middle security wise. Tailscale is more secure but a hassle on each client.
Plex isn’t perfect by any means but giving them $100 8 years ago was not unreasonable. If you get a ton of use out of Jellyfin then you really should be giving them at least that much for building you a media center with all those features. The alternatives are much more expensive than that. Also, software doesn’t develop itself. Give back to the people who make your life better or prepare for them to stop doing so.
Yeah, I’ve definitely gotten a huge amount of value out of plex lifetime. The problem with plex is the same as all commercial software. The profit motive is guaranteed to enshittify all of them eventually. Even companies that strike a good balance (e.g. Valve) are only a few deaths or bad decisions away from vultures and parasites taking over and destroying it for short term profit. I’ve personally experienced this over a dozen times in the last ~20 years, across most classes of software. That’s why I refuse to pay for most closed software. All of plex’s decisions over the last 5-10 years indicate it’s only a matter of time before they completely destroy the value proposition. I also won’t pay them a cent more, because of this trend.
The major problem with FOSS is the funding mechanisms available. Most require subscriptions too high to justify monthly when you want to donate to 10 projects, let alone 100; most don’t even do yearly, or require some large minimum (like $50 or $100). I assume this is entirely because of the banking fees involved. Most are also built on top of other FOSS that nobody ever donates to. IMO the only long term solution is for legislation that forces all banking and payments for FOSS/charities to be zero fee – for all parties – plus the development of a FOSS payment platform where you can setup a single recurring sub that is split among as many projects as you choose, but also splits a sub-portion among all FOSS dependencies. The platform could even provide a script that users can run to periodically update their donation list. I don’t want to donate to every FOSS dependency used in Jellyfin. I want all those dependencies to receive their cut, and for that to be the FOSS industry standard.
FYI I believe Jellyfin is cashed up and recommends donating elsewhere. I personally dropped $100 on VLC last year because I realised I’d never done that in 25 years of being a mainstay.
Wont be long before the terms change on what Plex considers “lifetime”
Could be, but that doesn’t remove the value I’ve gotten from it in the last 8 years. There’s no guarantee Jellyfin won’t enshittify or disappear either. That’s life, nothing is certain.
there’s no guarantee that Jellyfin won’t enshitify
Well, Jellyfin is released under the GPL license, which may not be a guarantee, but is probably about as good as you can get.
I bet you are really fun at parties.
Typically? Yeah I think so. Wanna come next time?
No I’m not good at parties.
Plex will soon charge you even more to stream your own media
Makes it sound like Plex is keeping your data (which let’s face it, is pirated anyway) behind a paywall, when in reality they are charging for the relay. It’s disingenuous to phrase it like that.
Now, I agree Plex is enshittifing, but let’s at least be fair in calling out the good and bad.
I bought a Plex lifetime subscription 13 years ago. I think it was about $75-ish. It worked fine, but they started getting more and more shitty.
I only want to share my collection across different devices on the LAN, and Jellyfin does that just fine.
I think I bought it when it was first offered and it was $50 (maybe 2010ish?). While they are getting closer and closer to enshittification, trying to switch those over who access my Plex server would be a headache. I’ll only do it if I have to, at this point. And it’ll likely take them revoking the lifetime pass for me to do so.
moving to open source and self-sufficiency is never a wrong choice
Some questions for he jellyfinners:
- can I make playlists
- can I shuffle them
Basically: I want [adult swim]
You may want to look into software such as ersatztv or disquetv
Yes, there are a few relevant features:
- Playlist: Exactly what you think. You can create a playlist of specific episodes/films/songs in whatever order you want. And yes, you can just shuffle that playlist if you want.
- Collection: Similar to a playlist, but more loosely structured and dynamic instead of a set list. Just an easier way to logically group together like items to make them easier to find. While this is not a hard-set list like a playlist, you can still shuffle it.
- Plug-ins like ErsatzTV: Allows you to set up a television-like scheduling system for a playlist/collection. Instead of how you normally use a Jellyfin playlist by simply choosing what you want to watch on-demand, with ErsatzTV, your playlist is constantly playing in the background and you just “tune into” whatever is scheduled to be playing at the moment. Like the olden days of watching broadcast/cable/satellite television. But YOU are the one who created that programming schedule.
Yes. They have a demo instance on their homepage with shows and movies you can test it out with
shit it proves i was right never to even consider it an option back in the SagetTV days if anyone remembers that google-murdered app
Jokes on them, I just use SMB with anonymous access enabled
Starwars padme meme: with read-only access right?
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)










